As a result, Giuliani today faces a political
establishment that makes Tammany Hall
look like a mom-and-pop operation. During
Tammany's heyday the city collected no taxes
on income or sales (the first sales tax was a
"temporary" measure of La Guardia's), so
there was limited revenue available. Giuliani
inherited a city with high taxes supporting
America's only municipal welfare state: one
of every six residents on welfare, one of
every five jobs in the public sector. The city is
by far the leading landlord and employer, and
it finances legions of private workers
providing social services - one of New
York's few growth industries the past
decade. Unlike Tammany's pols, today's
establishment can collect its money without
breaking laws. In fact, it commands the
moral high ground, at least among a
certain intellectual elite in Manhattan.
Almost any reform of Fiorello Hall can be
denounced as an attack on the poor.
"The biggest and largest special interest
group in the city," Giuliani says, "is the
intellectual establishment. New York is a
great intellectual center that has become one
of the most backward parts of America -
unwilling to think a new thought. I absolutely
love, and maybe I overdo this a little, to
suggest something new and then watch the
reaction to it. Sometimes I'm not even sure
we should do it, but I love to watch the
reaction from the so-called intellectuals. The thinking
establishment goes into convulsions over
the idea that we could ask people on
welfare to work, or that we should
fingerprint them to prevent fraud. It's almost
as if a secular religion had developed in
which these are the things that you must
believe to be considered an educated,
intelligent ant moral person."
Giuliani preaches less government and
more self-reliance, not just for individuals but
for cities -what he called, in a speech
earlier this year in Washington, a new urban
agenda. The speech repudiated a liberal
tradition dating to La Guardia and the New
Deal. It might have been headlined "RUDY TO
FEDS: DROP DEAD," although Giuliani put it
more diplomatically: "Set us free." He argued
that New York should stop begging to be
rescued by the Federal and state
governments, whose programs waste money
and impose pointless regulations. Instead of
going to Washington and Albany with sad
stories and a tin cup, New York should keep
its tax dollars and solve its own problems. It
should adopt the proposals that Giuliani in his
typical workaholic fashion, devised before
the 1993 campaign by interviewing hundreds
of experts and by studying reinventing
government proposals from the Manhattan
Institute. His vision is partly technocratic -
Giuliani loves to recite statistics and three-
point plans - but it is also intensely
moralistic.
Giuliani, who once planned to be a priest,
shares La Guardia's conviction that there is a
true path, that the world is divided into Us
and Them, that the city's savior should be
guided less by political ideology than by
personal virtue. He understands the
sentiment that La Guardia expressed to a
writer for The New York Times Magazine in 1934, in an article
headlined "A Full Day on the Job With the
Mayor." As the original Holy Terror denounced
the "cancer in the very heart of the city," he had
no doubts about his own saintliness. "I am
committing political suicide," he said, grandly
and inaccurately. "If I succeed in making this city
a better place in which to live, I shall feel that the
result justified the sacrifice."
9 AM. Arriving at Brooklyn Borough Hall, Giuliani
stops in for a meeting with Howard Golden, the
Borough President, and borrows three paper clips
to secure a trouser cuff that has come loose. They
go into the grand courtroom for the cabinet
meeting at which several dozen commissioners
and officials listen to a list of demands from the
Borough President, exhortations from Giuliani ant
a speech from Randy Mastro, the Mayor's chief
of staff. Mastro begins with a reference to a story
in the Times about Giuliani's recent penchant for
describing his own courage in making decisions.
"I want to tell a story about another example of
this Mayor's courage," Mastro says. "That's my
word, not The New York Times'." Mastro, who
prosecuted organized crimes under Giuliani at the
United States Attorney's office, has been up all
night dealing with the Fulton Fish Market. Some
workers, angry at a new company brought in to
unload fish at the wholesale market, had staged a
wildcat strike earlier in the week, whereupon
Giuliani went before the television cameras and
threatened to shut down the entire market. "I was
never prouder of this administration than at that
moment," Mastro, says, reporting that the threat
has worked. The market was open all night for the
usual wholesale deliveries of fish. "Organized
crime has been prevalent in the Fulton Fish
Market for 70 years, and it's not going to go away overnight," Mastro
concludes. "But
this Mayor has the guts and the courage to stay the course."
The commissioners applaud vigorously. Loyalty is vital in this
administration. Last year, when newspapers were quoting unnamed
commissioners complaining about budget cuts, all the commissioners were
summoned to City Hall by Peter Powers, Giuliani's First Deputy Mayor as
well as a close friend since high school "I told the commissioners,"
Powers would later recall, "how we discovered after the election that
David Dinkins had hidden the deficit so it was three times worse than
what we'd thought - but I never heard Rudy once complain that the money
ran dry. He took the hand that was dealt. I said to them: You can't
complain either. You've got to lead by example. You can't go back to your
deputy and complain, because then your deputy will complain to his or her
deputy, and it will get out in the press. If it's too hard for you to
make these cuts, tell me privately and we'll part friends. If you want to
stay on board, you can't criticize the Mayor.' I was upset. They all
applauded, and after that the complaining stopped."
The result, of course, has been a lot of complaining from other people.
Journalists say they've never seen such a secretive administration -
commissioners have become leery of releasing routine information or of
even speaking to reporters (especially those deemed enemies) without
clearance from the Mayor's office.
"It's an outrage to censor his commissioners that way," says the former
Mayor Edward I. Koch, who likes to tell of his own introduction to
Giuliani's autocracy. It was shortly after he criticized Giuliani for
having police remove candidates' signs from public property during last
year's gubernatorial campaign. "Rudy called me and told me I was wrong,
that it's illegal to put signs on poles. I started to say, 'I know it's
illegal' and he said, 'Don't interrupt me!' So I took the phone, cradled
it on my shoulder and read the newspaper while he talked. When he
finished, I said, 'Mayor, I know it's illegal' because I passed that
law.' I was trying to tell him that there's another way to enforce it,
but he didn't want to listen. It was the first time I realized how
thin-skinned Rudy is."
'It was amazing to me that people thought the squeegee problem wasn't
or couldn't be solved,' Giuliani says. 'A civilized society can't let
people go around the streets intimidating other people.'
Even a few Giuliani insiders have complained, although almost never on
the record, and even then generally not until they've gone elsewhere.
"It's a cult of personality around the great leader," one former aide says.
"They don't want anyone to question his
decision making. All they understand is intimidation. Rudy loves to shut
you down, cut you to the quick. If he wants your opinion, he'll beat it out
of you."
Members of the inner circle seem genuinely puzzled at such criticism.
Most of them will talk about Giuliani for hours, on or off the record,
without uttering a discouraging word - which, of course, helps explain why
they're still in the inner circle. They insist he's reasonable and open to
other opinions until he makes a decision. "Once a decision is made he
won't change it," says Richard Schwartz, the senior adviser to the Mayor.
"People call that stubbornness, but it's better than the alternative.
You're willing to put in all the work that radical reform requires because
you know he wont abandon you when it gets controversial With a regular
politician you wouldn't bother trying. We could never have tone welfare
reform if the Mayor had been intimidated by screaming advocates and
editorial writers." Aides explain their loyalty as both a political
necessity - even a hint of disunity would doom their assault on the
Democratic establishment - and as a personal obligation to him. They like
to tell of the small favors he did them and the hours he spent visiting
them in the hospital. The word "family" is used a lot.
At this morning's meeting the paterfamilias has good tidings for
everyone. Publicly, Giuliani remained neutral on a commission's report
that week recommending pay raises for himself and senior officials, but
here behind closed doors he announces that he'll come out shortly in favor
of salary increases. 'You deserve it," he tells his cabinet. This is not
going to be easy to explain to the public - officials with six-figure
salaries and city cars getting pay raises while subway riders are getting
a 25-cent fare increase. Golden, the veteran Brooklyn Democrat, leans over
to shake Giuliani's hand and announce, "This is a brave man." Everyone
applauds again.
10:40. A.M. After a brief press conference outside the cabinet meeting
Giuliani rides into Manhattan with his communications director, Cristyne
Lategano. She feigns disappointment that the news conference didn't deal
with a hot topic that week, Giuliani's decision to exclude Fidel Castro
and Yasir Arafat from the upcoming dinner and concert for the 50th anniversary
of the United Nations. "I'm surprised you didn't talk about Castro," Lategano
says jokingly. "Your position there - you haven't enunciated it
clearly enough." Giuliani, who has been happily excoriating the Cuban dictator
at every public opportunity, laughs and marvels at New Yorker's who like
Castro. "Maybe only in New York City can you actually find people who have a
romantic fascination with people who hate their country," he reflects. "It's
like having a romantic fascination with someone who hates your family."
11:10 A.M. Reaching City Hall, he ducks into his office, then
heads upstairs to give awards and praise to city employees
packed into the public hearing chamber. "New York City," he
reminds everyone, "is the best city in the world." Then back to
the van for a ride to midtown. On the way he reminisces about
his father: "He gave me the best definition of courage and
bravery that I ever heard. I asked him right before he died if
he was ever
afraid. He said he was always afraid-- 'If you're not afraid,
you're not courageous, you're just crazy.' He said the real test
is to overcome it, to not let it stop you from doing the things
that you think you should do."
Giuliani's father gave him an exceptional opportunity to learn
this skill at an early age. The father, a Manhattanite exiled to
his wife's Brooklyn neighborhood, was a Yankee fan. The son had
no particular allegiance until the day his father dressed him in
a Yankee uniform and sent him out to play in the heart of Dodger
territory. "The first thing they did was throw me in the mud,"
Giuliani recounted during a campaign commercial in 1993 that
briefly described his travails as the only Yankee fan in
Brooklyn. But the full story is much better: "One day a group of
four or five children put a noose around my neck and tried to
hang me on a tree. My grandmother saw this and started yelling
and they stopped. But my proudest moment was I didn't renounce
the Yankees. I kept telling them: 'I am a Yankee
fan. I am a Yankee fan. I'm gonna stay a Yankee fan.' All of our
family in that four-block area were Dodger fans, so this was a
constant fight for me - go out and acquire statistics to prove
that the Yankees were better than the Dodgers. The most
wonderful thing was that the last time they played in the World
Series, in 1956, the Yankees won - which I used for 10 years to
totally destroy all my Dodger relatives. To my father, it was a
joke. Put a Yankee uniform on the kid and it'll irritate all my
friends and relatives and it'll be fun. But to me it was like
being a martyr: I'm not gonna give up my religion. You're not
gonna change me."
12:30 P.M. After a speech to maritime union leaders, Giuliani
heads downtown to his inevitable lunch on the road - pizza,
today at John's on Bleecker Street. On the way, in between his
phone calls to aides, Lategano tells him of a letter in The
Times that morning from a restaurant
owner supporting the new anti-smoking law. "That's going to pass
away within six months," Giuliani says, referring to the
controversy about the law. "If you regulate people's behavior
somewhat differently, they'll respond to it."
1:45 P.M. Back in his office, Giuliani poses for photos with six
visiting teen-agers from Israel and makes small talk. ("Tel
Aviv, that's a teeming city.") Joseph Verner Reed, an under
secretary general at the United Nations, comes into lobby him to
attend the world leaders' speeches at the United Nations on
Sunday.
"I have the two best seats in the house for you," Reed says.
"You can listen to President Clinton, and when Castro gets up to
speak you can walk out."
"I can bang my shoe," Giuliani says. "I'll bring my spikes."
2 P.M. Time for the daily ritual in the Blue Room, which is
crammed with reporters and 17 television cameras. "It's like
going into the arena," Giuliani says. "I look forward to it."
Today the reporters want to know once again why he is excluding
Castro and Arafat.
"Some people," a reporter says, "think that if the party is
financed by public money, then you have no right to exclude
people, including Castro."
"Well," Giuliani replies, "some people think that, because you
say that, but you're wrong."
"Why?"
"Why? Because you don't bother to check your facts, which is a
very irresponsible thing to do."
"I'm asking you the--."
"Get your facts right in the premise of your question."
"I'm asking you to get the facts."
"No, you're not," Giuliani says, glaring at the reporter. "You
asked the question, 'Some people think that' - the fact is, it
is not funded by public dollars. The fact is that party is
funded by private dollars."
Some of the foreign correspondents here for the celebrations
appear startled to see the Mayor lashing out at a mild-mannered
reporter, but the regular press corps is nonchalant. It's used
to much worse. Giuliani came into office suspicious of the media
(particularly stalwarts of the liberal establishment, like The
Times and The New Yorker, that had supported Dinkins), and the
relationship quickly deteriorated to what reporters call a
historic low at City Hall. Many reporters blame the bad
relations on his communications director whom they consider
needlessly hostile; others say the real problem is that Lategano
is doing exactly what Giuliani wants. There are members of
Giuliani's inner circle who complain privately that the
30-year-old Lategano is too inexperienced. One of them says:
"Rudy needs someone who can get along with reporters and protect
him from his own instinct to retaliate when he's angry. He needs
someone to say, 'Don't worry, I'll handle this - and then let
things blow over. Instead she just agrees with him and even eggs
him on."
John Miller, the former spokesman for the Police Department who
quit in a huff after the Mayor's office ordered him to reduce
the size of his staff, says the Mayor is obsessed with
controlling press coverage "I couldn't figure out where he and
Cristyne found the time to get mad about every little detail of
the way he was covered," Miller says. "All it did was make the
press more hostile and produce worse coverage. Substantively,
this Mayor has had one triumph after another, but his public
image is suffering because he keeps stabbing himself in the eye
with an ice pick."
5:10 P.M. After two hours of telephone calls and meetings in
his office, Giuliani rides to the headquarters of the United
Jewish Appeal. He gets a standing ovation and is introduced as
the man with courage who "has changed the face of the city in
two years." He outlines the three goals he has never stopped
talking about since the start of the 1993 campaign: safer
streets, more jobs, better schools. He reminds everyone of the
disaster he inherited, a city that had lost 400,000 jobs in the
previous four years.
"Jobs were increasing in the rest of America, and
jobs were fleeing New York in numbers that approached the Great
Depression," he says. He blames the city's bloated government
and its many enterprises: vast real-estate holdings, 500 gas
stations 17 hospitals, even radio and television stations. "The
other governments that owned radio and television stations were
on the other side of the Iron Curtain The anomaly of this never
occurred to anyone." He tells how the welfare rolls had grown
from 850,000 to 1.2 million.
"A city of 7.5 million cannot sustain a million people on
welfare," he says. "You can't do it from the point of view of
the amount of misery and hopelessness that it creates among a
million people, and you can't sustain it because the number of
people supporting the people on welfare keeps diminishing."
The numbers have been declining since his administration began
verifying applicants' addresses, fingerprinting them and
requiring able-bodied single adults to work for the city.
Giuliani gets his biggest round of applause when he moralizes
about the workfare program. "In exchange for this benefit you
have an obligation to give something back," he says. "That
should be true for poor people, middle-class people, rich
people. That's part of the social contract that we were losing
in this city."
6:20 PM. Shaking hands as he walks along, Giuliani leads his
entourage down Park Avenue, pausing to look at a tie in a store
window. "It's ridiculous to pay $80 for a tie. I could find the
same thing for $20." At the Waldorf-Astoria he changes into
white tie and tails for the Alfred E. Smith political dinner. At
the reception Gov. George Pataki greets him with what looks like
sincere pleasure. Giuliani sees Koch and asks him how he's doing.
"I'm doing terrific, and so you are you!" Koch replies, eyeing
Giuliani playfully. "And you do have courage!"
11 PM. After dashing from the dinner to a live interview on the
10 o'clock news at WPIX-TV, Giuliani heads home, sounding
unaccountably energetic for a 51-year-old man who has just
worked 15 straight hours. He explains that he often likes to
write at this time of night. "Today has been a fairly easy day,"
he says when he gets out at Gracie Mansion. "I'm not tired. I'll
be up for another two hours."
'Just as in Eastern Europe, there's a building sense in the minority community that the principles enforced by the so-called leadership aren't going anywhere - the battle over more entitlements and more welfare and more government solutions,' Giuliani says.